Wayne Rooney Finally Settles the Messi vs. Ronaldo GOAT Debate
Former Manchester United forward Wayne Rooney has definitively weighed in on football’s most contentious argument – who truly deserves the title of greatest player of all time. The debate between Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi has divided football fans worldwide for over a decade, with the two legends amassing an incredible 13 Ballon d’Or awards between them.
Rooney brings a unique perspective to this conversation, having shared the pitch with both superstars – as Ronaldo’s teammate at Manchester United for five seasons (2004-2009) and as Messi’s opponent in several high-profile Champions League encounters.
Rooney’s History with Both Football Icons
Rooney and Ronaldo developed a complex relationship over the years. They played together 205 times for Manchester United before the Portuguese star departed for Real Madrid. Their relationship was briefly strained during the 2006 World Cup when Ronaldo’s actions contributed to Rooney receiving a red card in England’s quarter-final defeat to Portugal.
However, Rooney revealed he immediately addressed the situation: “I went over to him afterwards in the tunnel. I felt it was important to speak to him while it was still fresh and to do it face to face. He gave me a look as if to say sorry, but by then, I had my United head on.”
Regarding Messi, Rooney faced the Argentinian maestro three times in his career:
- 2008 Champions League semi-final (Draw)
- 2009 Champions League final (Messi won)
- 2011 Champions League final (Messi won)
Despite never playing alongside Messi, these encounters gave Rooney ample opportunity to appreciate the Barcelona legend’s extraordinary talents up close.
When discussing both players on The Overlap in May 2024, Rooney acknowledged their exceptional abilities: “I understand that people can say Messi, people can say Ronaldo – they are both incredible, probably the best two players to ever play the game.”
However, when forced to choose between them during a “winner stays on” game with Prime Video, Rooney didn’t hesitate to answer: “Lionel Messi.”
He elaborated on his preference: “For me, Messi has just got that little bit more flair, which I like in a player, so that’s the reason.”
This statement from someone who witnessed both players’ brilliance firsthand carries significant weight in the ongoing GOAT debate. While Rooney acknowledged the greatness of his former teammate, his ultimate preference for Messi’s stylistic approach to the game provides compelling insight from one of football’s most decorated English players.
The verdict from a player who competed at the highest level with and against both superstars adds another fascinating chapter to football’s most enduring debate.
Did Rooney make the right call? Who do you think deserves the GOAT title – Messi or Ronaldo? Share your thoughts in the comments section and join the debate that continues to captivate football fans worldwide!